Formula 1 Insight

Team Mate Troubles
31/10/2007
I see that Lewis Hamilton's biography, "My Story", (now there's an original title) is due to be released on November 5. Ignoring jokes about its brevity and so on, it might actually be quite interesting as a source of information on his years in the lower formulae and just how much input Ron Dennis had into his career.

Lewis Hamilton

The taster released to focus our attention goes straight to the dessert, however - the relationship between Lewis and his team mate, Fernando Alonso. I suspect that we are all hoping that Alonso does indeed leave McLaren soon so that we can move on from constant dissection of the squabble between these two. They are not the first team mates to have had a robust and ultra-competitive relationship, after all.

In fact, true friendship is pretty rare between F1 drivers, as mentioned by Alex Wurz recently. That is only to be expected, the nature of the sport demanding a level of competitiveness in its practitioners that is way beyond that in most other professions. The really surprising thing is that friendships between drivers do occur at all.

Alex mentions that he gets on well with Pedro de la Rosa (who doesn't?), Giancarlo Fisichella and Nico Rosberg, but the most obvious and genuine friendship between team mates this year has also been rather ironic in that it was ended rather abruptly by the team itself. I refer to Vitantonio Liuzzi and Scott Speed, of course, two drivers who had much to prove and only each other to be measured against. In the circumstances, it is quite remarkable that they seemed to enjoy each other's company and spent much time together in leisure pursuits away from F1 races. Have a look at the videos on Scott Speed's website to see just how genuine their friendship was.

Perhaps it was the hostility of the team towards them both that forced them together. But there is no doubt that, in spite of it being in each one's best interests to trounce his team mate on the track, they did not allow that to interfere with their personal lives. Critics would no doubt point at this as evidence of them lacking "the killer instinct" necessary to succeed in F1 and maybe they would be right. But I think it shows a healthy understanding that it is a sport in the end, something that is not more important than who or what you are.

"Nice guys come second," we say and are then astounded when our heroes prove to be selfish and spoiled, egotistical and vain. We react with surprise and shock when Alonso holds up Hamilton's pit stop and then tut-tut on being informed that Lewis disobeyed team orders. But we cannot have it both ways; if the bad guy always gets the prize, we can hardly expect the winner to be an angel.

So I find the tiff between the McLaren team mates unsurprising and slightly boring - without Alonso's constant feeding of the flames in his statements to the Spanish press, the business would be entirely unremarkable. Yet people will buy Hamilton's book to find out more; our appetite for human drama is insatiable. No doubt its sales will amount to "a nice little earner" for the latest British hero.

But I still say that the book I really want to read soon is Nigel Stepney's...

Clive

Alianora La Canta
What kind of marketer subtitles any book "My Story"? That was a clear missed opportunity, and if the marketers also think that the Hamilton/Alonso conflict is the best bit of the book, then I cannot see that the rest of the book would be particularly inspired. Though if a copy turns up at the local library, I'll still read it...

Going to the main thrust of the entry, I agree with you entirely. Sport, even at a fairly high level, doesn't have to involve everyone attacking each other or so little friendship. Some of my best off-line friends are competitors from swimming galas I've competed in (these include some friendships forged in top-level national galas). Friendship is not a sign of lacking competitiveness - it's a sign of maturity. It seems a bit strange that being nice off the track is viewed so negatively in terms of on-track ability.
Date Added: 31/10/2007

Clive
Well, I suppose when you're in a hurry to get the book on the shelves before Christmas, every moment spent thinking about a catchy title is time wasted. Even so, the lack of imagination in the chosen title does seem to augur pretty badly for the book. I wonder if there's a market for thinking up snappy book titles - and how much should I charge for each one...? :D
Date Added: 31/10/2007

Alianora La Canta
I don't know whether there's a market as such, but it is supposed to be the job of marketers to come up with snappy book titles...
Date Added: 31/10/2007

Clive
I guess there are good ones and bad ones... ;)
Date Added: 31/10/2007

F1Punter
Perhaps they were preoccupied with what to name his street?

Lewis Lane being my own personal favourite.
Date Added: 01/11/2007

Clive
LOL Yeah, most likely, F1Punter.

How about Hamilton Havenue...?
Date Added: 01/11/2007

Eric M.
This book is only the, what, sixth LH autobiography to hit the shelves? Are any of them any good? From what I understand he hasn't contributed directly to ANY of them, so I'm pretty skeptical. Oh well, as bad as this one is, it can't be as bad is the one that proclaimed him 2007 champion when it was released a few months back!
Date Added: 02/11/2007

Clive
A sign of the times, Eric. These days, as soon as anyone gets a "name" for themselves, the ghost writers are there, scribbling away like crazy. I'm so old that I can remember when biographies didn't get written until the person was dead. In fact, even autobiographies had to wait until the writer had one foot in the grave!
Date Added: 02/11/2007

verasaki
Can't wait to hear about his pedal car and toilet training.

Re: Speed/Liuzzi- one of the few drivers to come off with an actual "personality intacto" is David Coulthard. Perhaps because early in his F1 career he also fell foul of some team machinations, albeit not on the Toro Rosso scale . In his case it was pr and perhaps Bernie/Max trying to salvage a season, not his team manager grabbing him by the scruff of the nomex.

Now that I think about it, I wonder if maybe Speed isn't one of the brightest baubles in the box. If my employer shouts at me and grabs my collar, I get to sue and retire. I doubt these boys can-or actually want to do that. By being perfectly candid, because he had witnesses, he may have actually gracefully exited something he'd rather not be involved in anymore without actually having to forfeit anything. Was there anything remaining on his contract and how difficult is it to get out of a driver contract?

Date Added: 02/11/2007

Alianora La Canta
I saw one of those Lewis Hamilton books in the discount book shop yesterday afternoon. They were selling it for £4. Can't remember who wrote it, except that there were two authors, and it doesn't appear in the alarmingly long list of books on Lewis Hamilton Amazon are selling. I took one look at the first bit (no mention of a pre-F1 life) and the last bit (the story ended rather abruptly in about Hungary) and decided not to bother...
Date Added: 02/11/2007

Clive
Well, it says a lot if the books are already appearing in the discount stores. Could it be that the authors are not actually cashing in after all? Maybe the public aren't as easily fooled as they thought...
Date Added: 02/11/2007

Alianora La Canta
I think the book dated rather quickly, since it didn't even have the results of the WMSC case, let alone the season results in it. And there wasn't just one of these books in there - I saw about a dozen identical copies in three parts of the shop, in what appeared to be a desperate attempt to shift the stock.
Date Added: 03/11/2007

Clive
Definitely sounds like one publisher is going to be making a loss on that one.
Date Added: 03/11/2007

Alianora La Canta
Herd mentality rarely produces anything new, though, and it's new things that people want when they shell out £12 (the book's original RRP) or more on books.
Date Added: 04/11/2007

RSS feed icon RSS comments feed

Back to the main blog

Have your say

You may use some HTML in comments. For bold text use <strong></strong> and for italic text use <em></em>. If you know what you're doing feel free to use more complex mark-up but please no deprecated tags, break tags or JavaScript.


Enter the code shown above:

Name *

Comment *

Email *

URL


Copyright disclaimers XHTML 1.0 CCS2 RSS feed Icon